| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |




From the Departments of Molecular Endocrinology
*
and Molecular Genetics,
Quest Diagnostics Nichols Institute, San Juan Capistrano, California; and the Mount Sinai School of Medicine,
New York, New York
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1:13,000 births.5, 6
The prevalence of the mild NC form is estimated at 0.1% of the general population,4
but has been reported to be as high as 1:100 in New York7
and 1:27 in the Ashkenazim.8
Prenatal diagnosis and treatment for fetuses at risk for classic CAH are feasible and effective at preventing virilization of the affected female,9, 10, 11
however the appropriateness, ethics, and outcomes remain controversial.12, 13, 14
More than 90% of CAHs are caused by 21-hydroxylase deficiency, attributable to mutations in the gene coding for 21-hydroxylase (CYP21A2). The CYP21A2 gene is located on chromosome 6p21.3, in a region containing genes coding for proteins that determine human leukocyte antigen types. The 21-hydroxylase gene locus also contains a pseudogene, CYP21A, which is located
30 kb from CYP21A2, among the complement genes C4A and C4B. CYP21A is
98% and 96% homologous to CYP21A2 in its exons and introns, respectively; however, minor differences from the active CYP21A2 gene render the CYP21A gene inactive. The proximity and homology of CYP21A2 with CYP21A is thought to predispose the locus to meiotic crossovers between CYP21A2 and CYP21A, which may result in duplication or deletion of entire segments of the gene region.2, 15, 16
The most common CAH-related mutations include: a 30-kb deletion or genomic rearrangement/conversion fusing CYP21A2 with CYP21A (30%), IVS2-13 A/C
G (also called In2G, 28%), I172N (9%), V281L (9%), Q318X (4%), R356W (4%), exon 6 cluster mutation (I235N, V236E, M238K, 4%), G110
8nt (3%), P30L(2%), F306 + 1nt (1%), and P543S (1%).4, 17, 18
These events, with the exception of the P543S mutation, are derived from the CYP21A pseudogene, and together account for
95% of 21-hydroxylase deficiency. The remaining
5% of 21-hydroxylase deficiency is caused by rare sporadic mutations.4, 16, 19
New diagnostic initiatives include heel-stick filter-paper screening of newborns,20, 21 gas chromatography/mass spectrometry,22 and molecular techniques. Gene deletions and large conversions are typically detected by Southern hybridization16 or a recently described, semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR)/enzyme digestion-based method.23 Techniques for molecular diagnosis of point mutations include locus-specific oligonucleotide hybridization,24 amplification-created restriction sites,25 single-stranded conformational polymorphisms,26 locus-specific PCR,27, 28, 29 ligation detection reactions,30 and multiplex minisequencing.31 These methods have been reviewed by White and Speiser.4 Allele-specific PCR results may be difficult to interpret, unless the mutations identified can be confidently assigned to the CYP21A2 or pseudogene loci. The issue is complicated by the finding that back-conversion may occur, in which selected normal alleles and point mutations may cross back to the pseudogene. It is important, therefore, to establish initially whether gross recombination or conversion events have occurred, by examining the entire gene locus, before proceeding to mutation analysis. Locus-specific PCR, followed by a multiplex minisequencing step using 13 primers, has been shown to be a valid technique that can be used to detect the 10 most common point mutations.31 However, Southern blot analysis is still required for determination of genomic rearrangements for this method. Our approach is to perform locus-specific PCR using four primers external to the open reading frame to determine whether or not genomic rearrangement or deletion has occurred, followed by minisequencing using internal primers to detect internal CYP21A2 mutation.
Here, we describe a two-step molecular diagnostic approach, which is able to detect the most common gene conversions, point mutations, and deletions responsible for
90% of 21-hydroxylase deficiency without need of Southern hybridization. We use four locus-specific, duplex PCR reactions to detect the presence or absence of CYP21A2, CYP21A, and two products of genomic rearrangement. After PCR, amplicons are further analyzed by single-base extension with fluorophore-labeled nucleotides and separation/sizing by capillary electrophoresis (CE), to detect 12 common point mutations and a small deletion. Assay design, validation, and clinical application are discussed.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Restriction Analysis
To ensure locus-specific amplification of each of the CYP21 genes, we performed restriction analysis of the four PCR amplicons. After PCR, each of the four reactions were digested with 10 U EcoRI (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech, Piscataway, NJ) in 1x Buffer H (Amersham) for 2 hours at 37°C. Digestion products were electrophoresed on a 2% agarose gel to determine the size of digestion products.
Single Base Extension and CE
After amplification and agarose gel discrimination, 2 µl of duplex PCR product was digested with 2 U of shrimp alkaline phosphatase (USB, Cleveland, OH) and 1 U of exonuclease I (USB) in 1x shrimp alkaline phosphatase buffer (USB) in a total volume of 6 µl, to remove PCR primers and unincorporated dNTPs. Each digestion reaction was incubated at 37°C for 2 hours followed by 15 minutes at 75°C. After incubation, 5 µl of SNaPshot ready reaction mix (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) and 1 µl of primer extension (PE) primer mix (Table 2)
were added to each digestion reaction; total reaction volume, 12 µl. The oligonucleotides designed for minisequencing are of increasing length and end one base before each mutation base change.
|
Sequencing
Five of the CYP21A2 mutations provided for validation are not detected in the current assay, and were therefore cycle-sequenced in forward and reverse directions, to verify the results. PCR products were Exo/shrimp alkaline phosphatase-purified (as described above) and cycle-sequenced using Big Dye, Version 3.1 (Applied Biosystems), according to the manufacturers protocol. For complete CYP21A2 sequencing, the following primers were used: ME0096, 5'-CCAATGAGACTGGTGTCATTC-3' (5' untranslated region, forward); ME0097, 5'-CAGCATAGCAAGAACCCATC-3' (intron 2, reverse); ME0098, 5'-CCAAGAGGACCATTGAGGAAG-3 (exon 2, forward); ME0099, 5'-GCTGTGGAGAAACAGTGTGAG-3' (intron 3, reverse); ME0100, 5'-GGAAAGCCCACAAGAAGCTC-3' (exon 3, forward); ME0101, 5'-AGCATGAGAATGCAGCTGTG-3' (intron 5, reverse); ME0103, 5'-GAAGGAGCCTTTTGCTTGTC-3' (intron 7, reverse); ME0104, 5'-CACTGAGACCACAGCAAACAC-3' (intron 7, forward); ME0105, 5'-CCTCCACCACATTTTCACG-3' (intron 9, reverse); ME0106, 5'-CACAGTCATCATTCCGAACC-3' (exon 9, forward); ME0107, 5'-GACCAAGAAACTTTCGCTCC-3' (exon 10, reverse); ME0108 5'-TGTAAACACAGTGCTGCGAG-3' (exon 10, forward); ME0117, 5'-CACCCTCTGCAGGAGAGC-3' (intron 6, forward); ME0118, 5'-CTTGCTCAATGCCACCATC-3' (exon 8, forward); and ME0152, 5'-TAAAAACCTGGAGCCACTGG-3' (exon 5, forward). Sequences were aligned and examined using SeqScape software (Applied Biosystems).
| Results and Conclusions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
After PCR, amplicons were analyzed using a SNaPshot multiplex minisequencing kit for 11 common point mutations and a small deletion that alter protein function. Typical results from minisequencing are shown in Figure 3 A and C
. Because the SNaPshot ready reaction mix contains all four nucleotides, each labeled with a different color fluorophore, resulting single-base extension oligonucleotides are colored specifically according to the nucleotide that was added during the reaction. After CE and analysis with GeneScan and GenoTyper software (Applied Biosystems), nonoverlapping peaks with similar heights are produced that provide genotype information. Poly-T chains at the 5' end of most oligonucleotides (Table 2)
prevent the resulting peaks from overlapping, and help reduce secondary structure formation due to the addition of other sequences. The small 8-bp deletion commonly found in exon 3 was analyzed by two single-base extension reactions that add bases in the forward and reverse directions (G110
8nt-F and G110
8nt-R), based on the method of Krone and colleagues.31
To facilitate rapid scoring, the genotyper software was programmed to label peaks representing wild-type alleles as black, and peaks representing mutant alleles as red. Our minisequencing method and reporting chart also provides easy-to-read break-point information for gene deletions and large conversion events when a series of black labels change to a series of red labels, or vice versa (Figure 3 B and D)
.
|
Typical samples from individuals affected by CAH or carriers may produce any combination of the four PCR amplicons. Minisequencing results for amplicon 1 or amplicon 4 from mutant chromosomes exhibit nonoverlapping peaks, with one or more mutant red-labeled peaks. As in samples from normal individuals, amplicon 2 SNaPshot results indicate much heterogeneity. The presence of amplicon 3 indicates a 30-kb deletion allele or a large gene-conversion allele with the 5' end of CYP21A and the 3' end of CYP21A2. The presence of amplicon 4 in an affected individual may indicate an allele with a point mutation, a small deletion, or a gene-conversion event. These species, as well as the wild-type amplicon 4 detected in unaffected individuals and carriers, can be distinguished by the presence or absence of mutant alleles within the minisequencing results. Gene conversion or large deletion events and their breakpoint locations within amplicons 3 or 4 are indicated by a trend of red-labeled peaks followed by a trend of black-labeled peaks, or vice versa. Care should be taken when considering the peak for P453S, because this mutation is not transferred from the pseudogene and may be mistakenly identified as the tail end of a gene-conversion event.
Assay Validation
Twenty samples from CAH patients or carriers and 19 samples from healthy donors previously characterized for CYP21 mutations were analyzed during assay validation (Table 1)
. Clinical subtypes of the patients (if available) were determined based on clinical manifestations and the levels of relevant steroid metabolites and electrolytes in plasma and urine.35
Mutations from 15 of the CAH patient or carrier samples were previously determined using Southern hybridization for deletion analysis,19
allele-specific PCR for detection of the eight most common point mutations,35
and sequencing for the detection of remaining mutations. Three samples with a V281L mutation were collected at Quest Diagnostics for validation of the CAH Ashkenazi Jewish allele assay, and were previously shown to carry V281L mutations using a READIT assay (Promega Corp., Madison, WI). Mutations from the two remaining samples from CAH patients were previously determined by allele-specific PCR only.35
The validation panel was assessed for the presence of 13 mutations (the 30-kb deletion, 11 point mutations, and one small deletion), and had 11 different mutant CYP21A2 genes. Each of the 13 mutations examined in the assay was detected at least once.
All validation samples were correctly typed, according to the expected genotypes. Results from seven samples warrant further discussion. Amplicon 1 of sample 7215 had A, C, and G alleles at the IVS2-13 locus, revealing the presence of at least three copies of the CYP21A2 gene (Figure 4A)
. Although the individual carries both IVS2-13 A/C
G and Q318X mutations, they were suspected of being unaffected because of the third copy of CYP21A2. The laboratory that contributed the sample confirmed the presence of the third normal allele. Although our assay easily detected the third copy of CYP21A2, it does not determine the copy number of such mutations, nor the phase of compound heterozygotes. Therefore, similar samples sent to our laboratory for molecular analysis are given preliminary results only, until family studies are completed.
|
G/IVS2-13 A/C
G (data not shown). However, the laboratory that contributed the sample previously determined it to be IVS2-13 A/C
G/null. Lack of polymorphism by complete gene sequencing and family studies further suggest that the sample has an IVS2-13 A/C
G/null genotype. It is of note that neither IVS2-13 A/C
G/IVS2-13 A/C
G nor IVS2-13 A/C
G/null contain functional copies of CYP21A2 and are therefore consistent with a CAH phenotype. Samples 3904, 4451, 5467, and 6730 all contain mutant alleles that are not detected in the currently reported assay but were subsequently detected by complete gene sequencing (data not shown). Similar samples from patients who present all of the classic biochemical and clinical symptoms of 21-hydroxylase deficiency could be reflexed to analysis by complete gene sequencing. Samples 147 and 46500 are from an asymptomatic mother and her son with NC disease characterized by precocious pubarche and advanced bone age. Prior testing included all 12 point mutations examined in the current assay, but did not include deletion analysis. Both prior testing and the current assay detected the presence of a normal CYP21A2 gene (data not shown), and were therefore unsuccessful at identifying the genetic cause of the boys disease. Follow-up with complete gene sequencing also failed to find a CYP21A2 mutation.
Summary of Clinical Experience
At the time of submission of this article, 220 clinical samples had been analyzed for CYP21A2 mutations using the approach reported here. The majority of samples (n = 208, 95%) were from peripheral blood and 12 (5%) were prenatal samples (cultured amniocytes). Prenatal samples were tested only after confirmation of the indication for testing by a genetic counselor, and were tested in duplicate to confirm the analytical results.
Table 3
summarizes the results of 102 samples: 33 from individuals with confirmed CAH, 12 submitted for prenatal screening (one in four risk for classic disease), 26 from obligate carriers, and 31 submitted for general population screening (from partners of known affecteds and from obligate carriers with no known family history). The remaining 118 samples tested include samples from individuals for whom we were not able to obtain sufficient information (eg, baseline and stimulated 17-hydroxyprogesterone levels) to be confident of a 21-hydroxylase deficiency diagnosis, individuals with family history of CAH (not obligate), individuals submitted for simultaneous biochemical and molecular testing (from individuals who were later determined not to have 21-hydroxylase deficiency), and parents of suspected CAH patients. Simultaneous biochemical and molecular testing is a common occurrence in the commercial laboratory in contrast to the academic setting in which samples are submitted for molecular testing only after biochemical results confirm the clinical diagnosis.
The results shown in Table 3
were divided into three classes: no mutations detected, one mutation detected (carriers), and no normal CYP21A2 locus detected. Because the current assay provides evidence of two CYP21A2 genes only when there is heterozygosity or when they are amplified separately (ie, amplicons 1 and 4), normal individuals were further classified as negative for mutation with one normal allele (Neg1) or negative for mutation with two normal alleles (Neg2).
|
G, 11 I172N, 18 V281L, 4 G110
8nt, 1 Q318X, and 1 R356W mutations.
Twelve samples were from prenatal patients with a one in four risk of classic CAH. Parental samples are always genotyped before receipt of prenatal samples intended for mutation confirmation and transmission determination. Three of the prenatal cases had no mutations, five were carriers, and four had no normal copies of CYP21A2. Disease chromosomes detected include five 30-kb deletion or gene conversion, six IVS2-13 A/C
G, and two I172N mutations.
Twenty-six obligate carriers were tested using the current assay. Two of these had two CYP21A2 mutations (IVS2-13 A/C
G/I172N and V281L/IVS2-13 A/C
G). Both individuals were pregnant. One is a previously known affected individual who is currently being treated with dexamethasone, and the other is asymptomatic and had no problems becoming pregnant. In a third obligate carrier, we found no CYP21A2 mutant alleles. This individual is the mother of a boy with salt-wasting CAH and likely carries a rare mutation not detected by the current assay. This sample will be sequenced when our complete sequencing assay is ready for service. The remaining 23 patient samples had a single CYP21A2 mutation. These mutations included nine 30-kb deletion or gene conversion, nine IVS2-13 A/C
G, four I172N, one V281L, two G110
8nt, and two Q318X mutations.
Thirty-one samples from individuals having no previous family history of CAH were submitted for mutation screening (Table 3)
. Thus, the population screening category in Table 3
includes data only from partners of individuals with clinically diagnosed and treated disease and new partners of obligate carriers. Twenty-eight samples had no CYP21A2 mutations and three had one mutation. Mutations detected in this population include two 30-kb deletion or gene conversion mutant alleles and one V281L mutant allele.
Within our test population of 220 patient samples (440 chromosomes), we detected 137 mutant chromosomes. These mutant chromosomes can be further divided into 42 30-kb deletion or gene conversion chromosomes (30.6%), 31 IVS2-13 A/C
G (22.6%), 19 I172N (13.9%), 29 V281L (21.2%), 6 Q318X (4.4%), 6 G110
8nt (4.4%), 2 P453S (1.5%), 1 F306 + 1nt (0.7%), and 1 R356W (0.7%). We detected no chromosomes with P30L or exon 6 cluster mutations alone, although we routinely detect these mutations within 30-kb deletion and gene conversion mutant chromosomes.
Haplotypes Observed and Their Significance for Clinical Diagnosis
The inclusion of 11 point mutations and one small deletion in our assay, as well as the testing of several families and triads for prenatal diagnostics, allowed us to observe several interesting haplotypes that maybe useful for clinical diagnosis. During validation, we tested seven individuals with V281L mutation (Table 1)
. Two of these, 7257 and 7243, were samples from Ashkenazi NC CAH patients originally diagnosed by Southern blot analysis and locus-specific PCR. Southern blot results indicate the presence of CYP21A2, CYP21A, and a duplicated gene fragment in both samples. In our assay, both samples produced amplicons 2, 3, and 4, with identical minisequencing results for amplicons 2 and 4, but different results for amplicon 3 (Figure 4 B and C)
. Amplicon 3 of sample 7257 is mutant for P30L, IVS2-13 A/C
G, G110
8nt, I172N, I235N, V236E, M238K, V281L, and F306 + 1nt, and wild-type for Q318 and R356, indicating a deletion/conversion fragment with an intron 7 breakpoint. In contrast, minisequencing results from the product of PCR reaction 3 for sample 7243 revealed heterozygosity and, therefore, the presence of two or more amplicon 3 fragments. These amplicons were homozygous mutant for P30L, IVS2-13 A/C
G, and G110
8nt; heterozygous for I172N, I235N, V236E, M238K, V281L, and F306 + 1nt; and homozygous wild-type for Q318 and R356, indicating that one has an intron 3 breakpoint and the second has an intron 7 breakpoint. Our amplicon 3 fragment with the intron 7 breakpoint likely corresponds to a gene duplication with a large conversion event. Whether the product of deletion or conversion, the presence of multiple mutant alleles within this fragment indicates that it will not produce functional protein.
Another haplotype that was observed involves a single chromosome with two copies of CYP21A2: one wild-type copy and a second carrying the Q318X mutation. This chromosome was first observed in sample 7215 during validation (discussed above), and was observed in a further four individuals from two families. Although our assay facilitates observation of the second copy of CYP21A2 through A/C heterozygosity at the IVS2-13 locus, the Q318X mutation could be misinterpreted in an assay that does not identify two separate chromosomes. This haplotype likely corresponds to a rare duplicated 21-hydroxylase haplotype recently described by Baumgartner-Parzer and colleagues.36
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The structure of the CYP21 locus has complicated mutation testing since the gene was first identified and associated with 21-hydroxylase deficiency. The high level of identity between CYP21A2 and CYP21A makes PCR primer selection difficult because it is necessary to ensure that they correctly amplify the expected gene product. Therefore, most diagnostic groups currently test for mutations by Southern blot analysis and a separate PCR reaction for each point mutation or small deletion. However, the relatively compact size of the two genes (3.1 kb) allowed us to amplify each gene accurately by taking advantage of the limited heterogeneity outside of the coding region. The cis-arrangement of CYP21A2 and CYP21A on a single chromosome allowed detection of large deletions or conversions without a Southern blot by combining the primers into all four possible pair-wise combinations. Furthermore, inclusion of an internal control amplicon decreases the likelihood of false-positives by controlling for PCR reaction conditions. Although four PCR reactions per patient sample can be cumbersome in the clinical laboratory, we find this method preferable to Southern blot hybridization analysis.
When designing this assay, we expected that amplicons 4 would consist only of genomic rearrangement fragments with 5' ends corresponding to the CYP21A pseudogene and 3' ends corresponding to the CYP21A2 functional gene product, as illustrated in Figures 1C
, 3C
, and 3D
. However, we have seen amplicons 4 with completely normal coding sequences when using minisequencing and sequencing. Other workers in the area have noted the polymorphic nature of the CYP21 genomic locus,16, 19
and it is possible that the source of these wild-type amplicons 4 is gene conversion or polymorphism at the primer binding site. However, minisequencing or sequencing of each locus-specific PCR product safeguards the user from incorrectly assigning functionality to an allele in question. We think this method is at least as informative as Southern hybridization (if not more so) in terms of identifying functional gene products, because it directly tests for mutations within each product. When used in combination with family studies to determine phase of mutations, this assay provides informative haplotype data as is advocated by Koppens and colleagues.33
The minisequencing portion of this assay is modified from the principles described by Krone and colleagues.31 These reactions are multiplexed, semiautomated, and efficient, providing simultaneous detection of 11 point mutations and a small 8-bp deletion within a single tube. CE detection of labeled oligonucleotides allows accurate sizing/discrimination, and color-coded labels aid mutation and breakpoint reporting. This approach is clinically appealing because it reduces the total number of PCR reactions, compared with other methods, and uses fluorescent labeling of oligonucleotides and CE instead of radioactive labeling, as is optimally required in Southern blots. We have improved on the method of Krone and colleagues31 by optimizing primer design, reordering the minisequencing peaks in order, relative to the exons, and color-coding the peak labels according to whether they are wild-type (black) or mutant (red). Additionally, we have validated this technique in the clinical laboratory, the results of which are presented in this report.
Our clinical experience is limited to date, but results are beginning to indicate the sensitivity and specificity of the assay. We have detected no normal copies of CYP21A2 in 33 of the 33 known affected individuals tested to date. Results from our limited number (n = 12) of prenatal samples are close to the expected pattern of 1:2:1 for affected, carrier, and unaffected, noncarrierwe found 4 of 12 (33%) affected, 5 of 12 (42%) carriers, and 3 of 12 (25%) unaffected, noncarriers. Twenty-five of twenty-six (96%) obligate carriers had at least one mutant CYP21A2 allele; this is slightly different from the 100% expected carrier rate. The one obligate carrier in whom we found no mutation is the mother of a boy affected with salt-wasting CAH, so paternity is not likely to be the cause of this outlier. A rare or de novo mutation may be causing CAH in this child; however, we were not able to test this theory. In individuals without a family history of CAH, we found 3 of 31 carriers (
10%), a slightly higher rate than the expected 5% carrier rate,4
but this is not out of range for such a small sample population.
Although our test population contains several individuals from families, and therefore does not represent a population ascertained without bias, our observed frequencies of the various mutant chromosomes is similar to that seen by other groups within the US population.4, 17, 18 We observed more V281L mutations than expected (21% versus 9%), but this may reflect a higher proportion of individuals from at-risk populations (eg, Ashkenazi) than was seen in other studies.
Examination of Ashkenazi V281L mutant chromosomes reveals the possibility that amplicon 3 may be interpreted as a 30-kb deletion when it is actually a gene duplication with a large conversion event. Therefore, it may be difficult, in practice, to identify deletions without analysis of an entire family. Southern blots using both the CYP21 and C4 probes may provide more information about the presence or absence of a deletion. Regardless of whether the rearrangement event is the product of conversion or deletion, the minisequencing component of our assay allowed us to determine that the amplicon 3 associated with the V281L allele is nonfunctional, by examining the pattern of mutations. Ultimately, the ease, speed, and accuracy of our new PCR method, compared with the Southern method, outweigh the potential lack of discrimination between a deletion or conversion event.
The assay we describe has been optimized for use as a qualitative diagnostic tool, and is not optimal for quantitative assessment of copy number or determination of the phase in which mutations lie. In instances in which the IVS2-13 A/C>G locus is not multiply heterozygous, or two CYP21A2 genes do not amplify independently into amplification reactions 1 and 4, the presence of a functional gene may be difficult to detect. Therefore, difficult cases involving compound heterozygosity may require additional family studies. Prenatal diagnosis may also warrant further family studies, to establish the phase of multiple mutations.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Supported by Quest Diagnostics Inc.
Accepted for publication December 20, 2004.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. I. New Nonclassical 21-Hydroxylase Deficiency J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., November 1, 2006; 91(11): 4205 - 4214. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |